The Utah Utes find themselves in an intriguing and uncertain situation at quarterback after true freshmen Isaac Wilson, Brandon Rose and Sam Huard decided to enter the transfer portal. For head coach Kyle Whittingham, the path forward could hinge on the return of veteran quarterback Cam Rising, who has the option to play an unprecedented eighth collegiate season.

The potential return of Rising may have played a major role in the departure of Wilson and others. If Rising returns, he would undoubtedly be the starting quarterback for Utah as he has demonstrated his ability to perform at high levels even when healthy. Rising’s numbers speak volumes: In 2021, he threw for 2,493 yards, 20 touchdowns and just five interceptions. The following year, he improved to 3,304 yards, 26 touchdowns and eight interceptions and led Utah to the Rose Bowl before suffering a knee injury that sidelined him for the 2023 season. Despite his absence, Rising’s presence was felt in preseason expectations, with the Utes finishing as favorites to top the Big 12.

In 2024, Rising started strong, completing 34 of 66 passes for 555 yards, seven touchdowns and three interceptions before another injury cut his season short. His durability has become a major concern, and this injury story now raises a crucial decision: Should Rising return to college for an eighth season or try out for the NFL Draft?

The financial aspect of the NIL offers gives Rising a lucrative incentive to remain in Utah. Rising reportedly earned seven figures in NIL deals in 2024, a number that will likely increase if he decides to stay. In comparison, Rising’s injury history and age as an NFL prospect could limit his draft status to the late rounds or even undrafted free agent status. For a quarterback with Rising’s pedigree, staying one more year to improve his draft prospects might be the smarter move, both financially and professionally.

By returning to Utah, Rising could prove he can stay healthy for a full season, which is crucial for NFL scouts. His ability to push the ball downfield coupled with his versatility as a dual-threat quarterback would only strengthen his draft stock. Rising’s maturity and experience at the quarterback position make him an attractive prospect, but if he shows his durability and consistent production in 2025, he could become an early selection in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Kyle Whittingham channels the NBA legend with a five-word statement

For the Utes, Rising’s return would solidify their status as a powerhouse in the Big 12. A healthy Rising could lead Utah to another bowl game or even a spot in the College Football Playoff. His leadership qualities and on-field prowess would provide stability in a position currently fraught with uncertainty. However, if Rising decides to head to the NFL, Whittingham will need to find a new leader, either through the transfer portal or within the current roster.

The loss of Wilson, Rose and Huard has undoubtedly limited Whittingham’s options. Without Rising, Utah faces the daunting task of finding and developing a reliable signal-caller. On the other hand, if Rising returns, the Utes will gain a proven leader who can lead the team to new heights.

Rising’s decision is monumental for both his career and Utah’s program. Remaining in college for an eighth season offers him the chance to improve his NFL Draft profile while earning a significant NIL income. For Utah, his return would stabilize a crucial position and keep the Utes competitive in the Big 12 and beyond. If Rising can stay healthy and produce at his usual level, his draft stock will undoubtedly increase and Utah could be looking at a historic season. Whether it’s leading Utah to victory or preparing for the NFL, Rising holds the key to its future and the fate of the Utes.