Cody Bellinger’s move to the New York Yankees has brought a new love triangle to the MLB.

After it was announced that the Chicago Cubs had traded the 29-year-old outfielder for Cody Poteet on Tuesday, fans were quick to notice what could lead to some awkward moments in the Yankees’ clubhouse: Bellinger’s new teammate, Giancarlo Stanton, was once dating his wife, Bahamian Model Chase Carter.

Stanton, a Yankees right fielder, was first linked to Carter in July 2018 when Carter posted a series of Instagram Stories featuring the baseball player on the beach. A few months later, Carter Stanton posted again on her Instagram Stories – this time to commemorate his 29th birthday New York Post reported.

“Thank you for not pushing me in even though I know you wanted to 😂,” the model captioned a photo of the couple holding hands near a body of water. “Happy Happy Birthday.”

But the couple appeared to split in 2019, and Stanton sparked dating rumors with actress Priscilla Quintana in 2022 – although they never publicly confirmed a relationship.

For Bellinger and Carter, 2020 was the beginning of their love story. The couple began dating in July of the same year before welcoming their first daughter, Caiden Carter Bellinger, in November 2021 and their second, Cy Carter Bellinger, in April 2023.

“I think being a good dad is more important,” Bellinger told PEOPLE ahead of the birth of baby No. 1. “My girlfriend feels it; It grows in her belly, so she has a connection to it. I’m just there to support you and make sure she’s okay.”

The lovebirds announced their engagement in June 2023, with Carter showing off her new ring in a carousel of photos on Instagram. And although the couple never publicly attended a wedding ceremony, fans speculated that the duo had tied the knot after Carter posted a romantic photo on Instagram of himself hugging Bellinger on the beach and showing off what appeared to be wedding rings presented.

Alongside Stanton, Bellinger will make his Yankees debut in the team’s 2025 season opener in March. They hope to secure their 28th World Series ring after a disappointing loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers in the 2024 championship.