“The new ones are smaller. Maybe about 70% the size of the old ones,” one person said.

Although the eight-piece muffins are $3 cheaper than the previous 12-piece muffins, the math doesn’t work in customers’ favor. In fact, one Redditor did some price comparisons and found that the new muffins are a shocking 58% more expensive per ounce.

“So smaller, more expensive muffins…” says another comment.

As if dealing with smaller, more expensive muffins wasn’t enough, one person explained that they don’t taste the same either

“These are much worse. They are much drier, have less flavor, and are just boring and crumbly. I’m shocked they replaced the muffins because that’s what they’re pretty well known for. I will not buy them again,” they announced.

It’s not just customers who are frustrated by the muffin drama. As a result of the change, Costco employees will likely be tasked with dealing with angry customers.

“One of my best friends is a baker at Costco and she told me that she prepares for a lot of angry customers. The recipes will be completely different, it’s not just the size change,” said one person on Reddit.

Costco, please, we can only take a limited amount per calendar year.

Danielle Harling is an Atlanta-based freelance writer with a love of colorful spaces, craft cocktails, and online window shopping (usually for award-winning designer heels). Her previous work has appeared in Fodor’s, Forbes, MyDomaine, Architectural Digest, and more.