Lou Carnesecca, Hall of Fame coach who led St. John’s for 24 seasons, has died at 99

Lou Carnesecca, Hall of Fame coach who led St. John’s for 24 seasons, has died at 99

Carnesecca was a valued figure in city sports in his time. His affection for “Little Looie” never waned in a busy city with little patience for its players, coaches, executives and owners.

He coached St. John’s for 24 seasons in two stints – hosting a postseason tournament each year – and became the face of a university whose campus arena in Queens would eventually bear his name. A statue of him was unveiled ahead of the 2021/22 season. When Carnesecca was once asked to describe St. John’s during a question-and-answer session with the school, he said, “home.”

At home, he coached St. John’s in 18 seasons with at least 20 wins and 18 NCAA Tournament appearances. It was his hometown, where he finished with a record of 526-200 and notched 30 wins in 1985 and 1986. And it was his home where St. John’s became a founding member of the Big East Conference and a pillar of its success.

He was a three-time coach of the year in a league that began operations in 1979 and quickly established himself as one of the best in the country. His star players in those early years in the Big East included Chris Mullin, Mark Jackson and Walter Berry.

Carnesecca coached St. John’s to its fifth NIT title in 1989, although by that point the tournament had long been a poor cousin of the NCAAs. He was inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 1992, the year he retired.

“I never shot a basket,” he said during his introduction, forgoing a sweater for a smart suit. “The players did everything. There can be no game without players.”

He was an old-school coach who specialized in the fundamentals. And all the while, Carnesecca was a whirling, energetic presence on the sidelines, arms flailing, legs flailing, shirtsleeves flying, curled up in despair over a missed shot or an agonizing decision. But his antics never crossed the line into chair-throwing rage.

Carnesecca was simply consumed by his players, the love of a game was deep within him, a life spent in schoolyards, run-down gymnasiums and large arenas. He loved the “smell of sweat” and the “feeling of burning rubber” when sneakers hit a painted floor.

He remained the consummate gentleman in a sport populated by outsized egos, bitter recruiting wars and the relentless pursuit of the next assignment. Mike Tranghese, a former Big East commissioner, once called him “our soul and our conscience” and “one of the giants of the game.”

Carnesecca led St. John’s to Big East tournament titles in 1983 and 1986. His teams reached the Elite Eight of the NCAA Tournament in 1979 and 1991 and spent more than 70 weeks in the top 10 of the AP Top 25. A banner noting his 526 wins at St. John’s hangs from the rafters at Madison Square Garden.

He coached more than 40 NBA draft picks, including Mullin, Jackson and Malik Sealy among 11 first-round selections.

Despite all this, Carnesecca never made himself too famous. He always believed that a difficult loss should never stand in the way of a glass of Chianti and fettuccini with Bolognese sauce. He held seminars around the world, making friends and raising toasts wherever he went. He was there with a kind word and a witty joke in his breathy, gravelly voice. His family tree goes back to Tuscany, but he could keep up with the best Borscht Belt comics.

“I don’t know if there’s anyone else who coaches like him,” longtime UConn coach Jim Calhoun once told the Hartford Courant. “Even if people hate the Big East, no one hates Looie. If you like basketball, you like Looie. If you like kids, you like Looie.”

Luigi P. Carnesecca was born on January 5, 1925 to Italian immigrants. He grew up in Manhattan’s East Harlem neighborhood, living above his father’s grocery store and deli. He took his legacy seriously and cheered on New York Yankees like Tony Lazzeri and Joe DiMaggio.

After a stint in the Coast Guard during World War II, he became a coach at his high school – now longtime basketball star Archbishop Molloy. In 1958, he accepted an assistant position at St. John’s, his alma mater, where he had played baseball on a team that reached the 1949 College World Series, but not college basketball.

He worked under Joe Lapchick for eight seasons, and the Hall of Fame coach’s lessons about humility and hard work lasted a lifetime. Carnesecca later passed on to Mullin some advice he had received from Lapchick: “Today a peacock, tomorrow a feather duster.”

“I learned more from Coach Lapchick clearing his throat than I could have learned at any other clinic,” Carnesecca said.

He succeeded Lapchick in 1965 and the 20-win seasons quickly piled up. But even after five years, Carnesecca was not immune to the siren song of the professionals. He coached the New York Nets of the American Basketball Association for three years, and Rick Barry was one of his players.

Years later, during a 1982-83 season in which his St. John’s team finished 28-5, Carnesecca reflected on the pressures of college coaching and his time in the ABA.

“I lost 50 games as a professional coach – that was pressure,” he said. “I didn’t feel like getting out of bed. My mom could coach this team.”

His stay with the professionals didn’t last long. Carnesecca knew this wasn’t his natural habitat. He said he could only give the same halftime speech so many times. In 1973 he returned to St. John’s.

Successful seasons followed in quick succession, even though his city was no longer the draw for recruits of past generations. The best high school players moved south and west to college campuses with gleaming arenas and didn’t need the commercial pull of New York to burnish their brand.

When asked why he didn’t broaden his base when looking for players and venture beyond his city’s five boroughs, Carnesecca knew he had plenty of talent in his neighborhood. He pulled a subway token – now a relic of past generations – out of his pocket.

“That’s my recruiting budget,” he said.

In the 1984-85 season, Carnesecca and St. John’s conquered New York, harkening back to a time when schools like City College and NYU played a role not just in the Big Apple but throughout college basketball. The Redmen – their nickname was changed years later to the “Red Storm” – played tough, exciting games in a packed Madison Square Garden against Syracuse teams coached by Jim Boeheim, Villanova teams coached by Rollie Massimino and Georgetown Teams coached by John Thompson and led by Patrick Ewing.

Then the saga of The Sweater took shape. Over the years, Carnesecca repeatedly recounted his astonishing entry into the fashion world like an embellished family story.

Essentially, St. John’s was preparing for a road trip to Pittsburgh in January, and Carnesecca was under the weather. The building would be drafty and his wife said it would be good if he wore a sweater. He found one given to him by an Italian basketball coach. It was a brown sweater with wide turquoise stripes. It never made it to the pages of GQ.

“It’s ugly, isn’t it?” said Carnesecca.

Doesn’t matter. Mullin hit the game-winner at the buzzer and the coach had his lucky charm. He stuck to the sweater. Along the way, St. John’s ended Georgetown’s 29-game winning streak and rose to No. 1 in the rankings.

But there were also two lopsided losses to Georgetown during the sweater’s 16-2 run – one when a grinning Thompson outshone his popular rival by wearing a duplicate on the court at busy Madison Square Garden, which was called “The Sweater Game” became known, attracting a large television audience in February 1985.

With his luck running out, Carnesecca finally put the sweater away. He then went to the NCAA tournament wearing a tan snowflake number. St. John’s defeated Southern, Arkansas and Kentucky before a win over North Carolina State in the West Regional final sent Carnesecca to the Final Four.

“When I go to my grave,” he said, “I will remember this.”

St. John’s traveled to Lexington, Kentucky, along with two compatriots from the Big East – Georgetown and Villanova – and Memphis. St. John’s edged Georgetown in the semifinals and trailed 32-28 at halftime. But the Hoyas pulled away and won 77-59, with Mullin leading by eight points.

“I think we tried everything,” Carnesecca said of Georgetown, which was then defeated by Villanova in one of sports’ greatest championship games.

After his retirement, Carnesecca was succeeded by a parade of coaches at St. John’s, including Mullin. Even in his 90s, about three decades without a coaching career, Carnesecca made his way to The Garden when the Red Storm were there. His gait may have been cautious, but his mind and intellect were quick, and the crowd roared as the giant screen swung toward him. The coach was at home.

“It will be very difficult to put the ball down, but the time has come,” he said upon retiring at the age of 67. “There are actually two reasons. I still have half of my marbles and I still have a wonderful taste of basketball in my mouth.”

The school said Carnesecca is survived by his wife of 73 years, Mary, as well as daughter Enes and son-in-law Gerard, a granddaughter and a niece and nephew, as well as his extended family.

___

An earlier version of this story corrected Carnesecca’s record at St. John’s.

___

Fred Lief, a retired Associated Press sportswriter, was the lead author of this obituary. Former AP sports writer Paul Montella contributed to this report.

___

Get poll alerts and updates on AP Top 25 Basketball throughout the season. Register here. AP Women’s College Basketball: https://apnews.com/hub/ap-top-25-womens-college-basketball-poll and https://apnews.com/hub/womens-college-basketball

FILE - Former St. John's men's basketball coach Lou Carnesecca smiles during a news conference to announce the hiring of his former player and retired NBA basketball All-Star Chris Mullin on April 1, 2015 in New York. (AP Photo/John Minchillo, File)

Photo credit: AP

Enlarge image icon

Photo credit: AP

FILE - Lou Carnesecca coaches his St. John's team from the sidelines during the game against Niagara in New York on November 23, 1991. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan, File)

Photo credit: AP

Enlarge image icon

Photo credit: AP

FILE - Former St. John's head coach Lou Carnesecca speaks to the media after Rick Pitino was introduced as the new St. John's basketball coach during an NCAA college basketball press conference at Madison Square Garden in New York on March 21, 2023 became. (AP Photo /Corey Sipkin, File)

Photo credit: AP

Enlarge image icon

Photo credit: AP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *