The demand for one of Greta Gerwig’s most famous collaborators to appear in her iteration of The Chronicles of Narnia is understandable, but the debate over who this actress should play may be too complicated. After their huge success Barbiethe Oscar-nominated director, signed on to write and direct the first two Netflix films Chronicles of Narnia start anew. There’s been a lot of speculation about how Gerwig will put her own spin on Narnia, including which of her former collaborators might star in the first film, which Jason Isaacs has teased The magician’s nephew.

Timothée Chalamet is seemingly the perfect Mr. Tumnus; More difficult to place is four-time Oscar nominee Saoirse Ronan, the star of Gerwig’s film Lady Bird And Little women. Ronan is too old to play Susan Pevensie, although as a teenager she would have been perfect for this Narnian heroine. However, when some of Saoirse Ronan’s best films are directed by Gerwig or feature some sort of historical fantasy, she’s there Narnia still seems to be a given. However, The character Ronan is intended to play in one or more Narnia Movies can be a lot simpler than fans realize.

Saoirse Ronan was set to play the White Witch in the new Narnia films

The White Witch represents the most exciting casting opportunity for Gerwig’s Narnia films

When Narnia focuses so much on the child heroes that there are few significant adult characters. The adult, human character that is in the foreground Narnia in the cultural zeitgeist is the White Witch, the main villain of both The magician’s nephew And The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. It was discussed who should play the role of the White Witch in Gerwig’s film NarniaRonan was largely left out of the fan lineup. But it could be as simple as pairing Gerwig’s preferred leading lady with the available character suitable for her age.

If it’s not the White Witch, whose name is Jadis, Ronan’s character comes into question Narnia are scarce. She could play the mother of the Pevensie children, provide the voice of one of the animal characters, or perhaps portray one of the Narnian nymphs who exist in the background of the story and serve primarily as a genre example. All of these are supporting roles that would potentially be a waste of Ronan’s talents. If the standard is for Ronan’s character to be the focus of Gerwig’s story, it would be disappointing if she was only minimally involved in the plot.

The White Witch isn’t your typical Saoirse Ronan character, but she would still be great

Nobody should underestimate Ronan’s ability to play different characters in each Gerwig film

The reason why Ronan isn’t people’s first choice for the White Witch is obvious, as it’s not a character archetype they would associate with her. Especially in Gerwig’s films People are used to Ronan playing the young, romantic, flawed heroine at the center of a coming-of-age story. However, since Ronan is a talented and acclaimed actress, she shouldn’t be underestimated when it comes to playing completely new characters. Notably, Saoirse Ronan was a frontrunner for the role of Yelena Belova, a far darker and more action-oriented role than her usual role before her Little women Co-star Florence Pugh was cast.

Additionally, further analysis of Ronan’s career and how the White Witch has been portrayed in the past reveals some resonances with the character. Ronan plays the title character in Mary, Queen of Scotlandthat captures both a regal dignity and some emotional nuances of fear, kindness and grounded courage. Jadis should be a dominant character, but developing her character to help the audience understand her desire for power could be even more compelling; Ronan’s performance could also help achieve this. Furthermore, the performance of Ronan’s potential predecessor actually seems like something she could pull off.

Swinton’s Jadis is often stoic, even calm, in her manipulations, speeches, and physical fights.

The White Witch was beautifully portrayed by Tilda Swinton in one of the best fantasy film villain performances of all time. Swinton’s Jadis is often stoic, even calm, in her manipulations, speeches, and physical fights. When she strikes, it seems like an elaborate part of her plan because it happens when she needs to scare someone. Should she actually lose control, her anger is still sharp and targeted like a knife. The Jadis doesn’t have too many unusual characteristics for Ronan – She could actually be a very reserved, yet frightening character, fitting Ronan’s sometimes mysterious behavior.

Saoirse Ronan and another leading actress could one day become Greta Gerwig’s Narnian Witch duo

Saoirse Ronan and Margot Robbie are the epitome of the leading actors in Greta Gerwig’s filmography

Additionally, Casting Ronan as the Narnia Witch now or later could lead to an epic collaboration down the line. depending on how Narnia Restart expires. There are currently two of Gerwig on board Narnia films, but it remains unknown whether she is considering adapting future installments after them. If she stays with the series long enough, she will make it to the story of the Lady of the Green Kirtle, the main villain of The silver chair who is often associated with the White Witch. This scenario would allow Gerwig to cast both Ronan and Margot Robbie as famous Narnia villains.

If Ronan is the face of Gerwig’s historic career, Robbie is the face of her bold new filmmaking, since the more experimental project of Barbie. Robbie is the more obvious choice for the role of the White Witch, but if both were on board – Robbie playing the Green Lady and Ronan playing the White Witch, or vice versa – it would really feel like a Greta Gerwig project. Ronan and Robbie haven’t played alongside each other since then either Mary, Queen of Scotland (in which Robbie plays Queen Elizabeth I). That they would be the new Narnian witch duo would be amazing in many ways.

Saoirse Ronan will probably end up playing this Narnia character (and it will be a missed opportunity)

Ronan’s latest work will likely see her play a “real world” character in Narnia

However, The character Ronan will likely end up playing is Mrs. Pevensie. Given the obvious character associations, it would be a shame that the producers, Netflix or Gerwig weren’t willing to take a chance on her. Netflix is ​​likely hoping that Gerwig will bring in her usual roster of star actors to increase the film’s marketability, and will look to cast significant people in every role, even the smaller ones. Some will argue that she will shine with Ronan’s talent and add something to the film even with the shortest scenes.

However, The Chronicles of Narnia could fail to become an even more layered film if Saoirse Ronan is kept away from the fantasy, where she could add depth to the magical tale with a mesmerizing performance.

Ronan has also received a lot of attention for her starring role in the recent release of flashplays a character with several coincidental similarities to Mrs. Pevensie. flashRita is also a mother who is separated from her child when he is sent away from London during World War II. The film admittedly shows Ronan’s potential to make Mrs. Pevensie a more formidable character. However, The Chronicles of Narnia It could be that keeping Saoirse Ronan away from the fantasy world makes the film even more layered, where she could add depth to the magical tale with a mesmerizing performance.